CTVBOS#14 mini – Case for Three Detectives by Leo Bruce


This is a book that I had not heard of before, a bit of a surprise given the premise. After all, here we have pastiches of three of the best known GAD detectives (Poirot, Wimsey and Father Brown) in the same space, with slightly different approaches, solving the same crime. And with a good deal of humour and lots of the standard golden age tropes. What’s not to like?

The novel is generally well regarded and I was really looking forward to reading it. Unfortunately I really am in two minds. There is indeed an awful lot to like. But, there is something that I find difficult to explain that just doesn’t work for me.

OK – the set up. We have Dr Thurston, his well liked wife and a collection of house guests and servants. After dinner Mrs Thurston meets her death in a somewhat bloody manner. We have a diverse collection of suspects both “upstairs and downstairs” and, at its heart, a locked room mystery. Into this walks the beer-swilling local copper Sergeant Beef who is almost too dim for words but reckons he knows exactly whodunnit. But – of course – what would a provincial plod know? Parachuted into the all of this are our three amateur sleuths Lord Simon Plimsoll, M. Amer Picon and Monseigneur Smith. No – it doesn’t take one of these three to work out who they are meant to be (if you get my drift…). And here is mystery number one. Why are they there? Maybe I was napping but their appearances on the scene just seem to “happen” for no obvious reason. Ok – suspension of disbelief and all that but it all seems a bit other-worldy.

Although the pastiches are rather obvious (just take their names!) I suppose they could have been even more extreme and that would have been irritating. As it is, Bruce has the good sense to tone it all down after the initial introductions and he actually presents a pretty well drawn picture of the MO of each of the sleuths as they go about their business in their very different ways. Lovers of order will like this book. The investigations follow a well-defined structure through the rest of the novel. Something like …..murder happens —- aftermath —- round of interviewing etc by Plimsoll, then Picon, then Smith —- some other stuff happens —– next round of deductions by the 3 amateurs in the same order….. etc etc. And all through this we have some decent backstory plot and the constant presence of Beef. And – you know what – maybe Beef isn’t that daft after all? Mmmmm.

What else do we have? The world of those “below stairs” and their relationship with those they serve is quite intriguing and – I guess – somewhat risque in places. The suspects are an interesting lot: some of the characters are bizarre (the padre in particular is way off-scale) but some of them are quite bland. Mmmmm again..

The denouement consists – you guessed it – of three solutions by the three sleuths.  Which is the right one?  Or is it even one of the three presented: is the story actually finished?  In the end, the finale is quite satisfying, entertaining and was a genuine surprise to me – so well done Mr Bruce.  

But, that aside, I’m struggling to summon up much more enthusiasm so I will leave it at that!

Overall it’s a qualified recommendation. Enjoyable, amusing, interesting but something I just can’t quite put my finger on that just doesn’t quite work.  That’s the mystery!

One thought on “CTVBOS#14 mini – Case for Three Detectives by Leo Bruce

  1. I’ve not read this for a nuber of years, but I seem to remember some meta comment in the narrative about how there’s always a genius sleuth nearby wheever someone commits a crime. So you’re absolutely right — it makes no sense, and that’s sort of the point 😄

    I remember being blown away by this; not just the accuracy of the pastiches, but the general structure and the distinct solutions that emerge. It was early in my locked room reading, and the idea of someone being able to come up with four answers to an impossible crimes just blew my mind.

    So…well, it seems I liked this for all the reasons you didn’t. If you have any further interests in pastiches, though, Murder in Pastiche, by Marion Mainwaring comes highly recommended — not a good mystery at all, but she savages the likes of Nero Wolfe, Mike Hammer, Miss Silver, etc. in merciless fashion.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create your website with WordPress.com
Get started
<span>%d</span> bloggers like this: